q & a ||
Nembutsu Chanting And Death-bed PrayingI don't believe in Nembutsu, Requiem or praying at the death-beds. When I look at a dying or a cold, stiff, dead person I only wonder if this person had practiced enough during his living days or not. If he had, then all the praying for him would make no difference. His soul would move up regardless, just like oil on water. But had he not practiced, his would sink like a stone thrown into a pond. People pray and chant (Nembutsu) at the death-bed more as a formality than any practical purpose. You go ask all highly ranked monks and respected scholars and see if they can point out any part in any sutta mentioning monks praying to help to lift a person's soul after he had already died.
In my opinion, there is only one special situation and that is when a person is still alive but very near death; where some guidance may be provided through words from Buddha and saints. This is the situation of visiting at a sick-bed, different from the scene of crowds gathering around a death-bed and praying loud and long in the hope of somehow rescue the dead person's karma. The person is either already dead or in a terminal coma (dying state of not knowing, not hearing) - yet people keep crowding around him, praying from one sutta after another, some even in Pali language! In all the suttas I have read, there is not one mention of monks visiting and praying to a dead or comatose person.
Buddha, Sariputta, Moggallana or Ananda all may have visited and provided guidance to a few persons who were very ill but who could still hear, understand and reason. The sick may have been asked succinctly (and not subjected to long chanting of a winding sutta):
"Are you coping with the suffering? Any regret or fear?"
"It is better to have a sick body than a sick mind. Mind sickness is from sadness or worries caused by the many troubling terrifying emotions of the body."
"Do you see me as a body form? Or does body form appear in me?"
Once there was a monk who was so enraptured with the Buddha that he never wanted to be out of his sight. When this monk became sick one day and was unable to see the Buddha, he became despondent. The other monks asked him why he was so unhappy. He explained that he was depressed because he could not see the Buddha, who then came to visit the sick monk and said to him: "What do you see in this vile form? There is nothing to see in that. Whoever sees me, sees the Dhamma, whoever sees Dhamma, sees me. "
This can only be applied to persons who can still hear and mentally clear enough to be able to reason. These bits of advice are helpful and make it possible to lift the ill and lost person from his suffering and darkness, that would be a true form of spiritual assistance.
The Nembutsu service of modern days, on the other hand, may inadvertently imply one does not have to practice Buddhism at all. Some may just wait until their last gasps then get monks and nuns to come and pray long and loudly around their death bed. Some may agree with me when I ask: If that would work then why bother going to the temples or meditation centers to learn anything? In a difficult environment; bad meals, and mozzy bites?
We must solve problems of our mind, with the help of surrounding people, to practice meditation, and purify our souls together. Don't just do nothing and then when you're dying ask people to come and pray for you - that is just simply cheating.
You hear my words now but that's not enough. Wait until you're on your last breaths and only then start looking for a solution, then realise all your practice of Buddhism is only superficial - like rubbing sports creams in hope to get rid of cancer.
Đã Phát Hành
Nhật Tụng Kalama
Địa chỉ liên lạc để có sách:
☎ Cô Trần Thị Ngọc Tuyết: 0934183043
(Có ship COD qua bưu điện).
☎ Anh Trần Khắc Tuấn: 0906666378
🛋 Thỉnh sách trực tiếp tại địa chỉ:
✉ Độc giả ở Mỹ thỉnh sách xin liên lạc: